clear
Sunday June 25th, 2017 8:09PM

Justices say law on offensive trademarks is unconstitutional

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court on Monday struck down part of a law that bans offensive trademarks, ruling in favor of an Asian-American rock band called the Slants and giving a major boost to the Washington Redskins in their separate legal fight over the team name.

The justices were unanimous in saying that the 71-year-old trademark law barring disparaging terms infringes free speech rights guaranteed in the Constitution's First Amendment.

"It offends a bedrock First Amendment principle: Speech may not be banned on the ground that it expresses ideas that offend," Justice Samuel Alito said in his opinion for the court.

Slants founder Simon Tam tried to trademark the band name in 2011, but the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office denied the request on the ground that it disparages Asians. A federal appeals court in Washington later said the law barring offensive trademarks is unconstitutional and the Supreme Court agreed.

The Redskins made similar arguments after the trademark office ruled in 2014 that the name offends American Indians and canceled the team's trademark. That case, before a federal appeals court in Richmond, had been on hold while the Supreme Court considered the Slants case.

Tam insisted he was not trying to be offensive, but wanted to transform a derisive term into a statement of pride. The Redskins also contend their name honors American Indians, but the team has faced decades of legal challenges from Indian groups that say the name is racist.

Tam said the band was "beyond humbled and thrilled" with the ruling.

"This journey has always been much bigger than our band: it's been about the rights of all marginalized communities to determine what's best for ourselves," he said.

Despite intense public pressure to change the Redskins name, team owner Dan Snyder has refused, saying in the past that it "represents honor, respect and pride" for Native Americans. Snyder issued a quick statement after Monday's decision: "I am THRILLED. Hail to the Redskins."

Redskins attorney Lisa Blatt said the court's decision effectively resolves the Redskins' longstanding dispute with the government.

"The Supreme Court vindicated the team's position that the First Amendment blocks the government from denying or cancelling a trademark registration based on the government's opinion," Blatt said.

Trademark office spokesman Paul Fucito said officials are reviewing the court's ruling and planned to issue further guidance on how they will review trademark applications.

Indian groups opposing the Redskins said the ruling does not change the fact that the name "is a dictionary-defined racial slur."

"If the NFL wants to live up to its statements about placing importance on equality, then it shouldn't hide behind these rulings, but should act to the end this hateful and degrading slur," said a joint statement from the National Congress of American Indians and the group Change the Mascot.

The ruling means offensive trademarks can no longer be denied, even for names that intend to disparage individuals or groups of people, said Megan Carpenter, dean at the University of New Hampshire School of Law and an expert on trademark law.

While the justices all agreed on the outcome, they split in their rationale. Alito rejected arguments that the government has an interest in preventing speech that is offensive to certain groups.

"Speech that demeans on the basis of race, ethnicity, gender, religion, age, disability, or any other similar ground is hateful; but the proudest boast of our free speech jurisprudence is that we protect the freedom to express the thought we hate," Alito said in a part of his opinion joined by Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Clarence Thomas and Stephen Breyer.

Writing separately, Justice Anthony Kennedy stressed that the ban on disparaging trademarks was a clear form of viewpoint discrimination forbidden under the First Amendment.

"A law that can be directed against speech found offensive to some portion of the public can be turned against minority and dissenting views to the detriment of all," Kennedy said in an opinion joined by Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Sonya Sotomayor and Elena Kagan.

Justice Neil Gorsuch took no part in the case, which was argued before he joined the court.

Government officials said the law did not infringe on free speech rights because the band was still free to use the name even without trademark protection. The same is true for the Redskins, but the team did not want to lose the legal protections that go along with a registered trademark. The protections include blocking the sale of counterfeit merchandise and working to pursue a brand development strategy.

Critics of the law said the trademark office has been wildly inconsistent over the years in deciding what terms are too offensive to warrant trademark protection. The government has in the past rejected trademarks for the terms "Heeb" and "Injun," but allowed those for companies such as Baked By A Negro bakery products, Midget Man condoms, and Dago Swagg clothing.

___

Associated Press writer Stephen Whyno contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Local/State News, Associated Press (AP), AP Sports, AP Online Football, AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP Entertainment, AP Online Recordings News, AP Business, AP Sports - NFL
© Copyright 2017 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Justices say law on offensive trademarks is unconstitutional
The Supreme Court on Monday struck down part of a law that bans offensive trademarks in a ruling that is expected to help the Washington Redskins in their legal fight over the team name
10:35AM ( 8 minutes ago )
Sizzling heat wave creates health hazard in southwestern US
The Southwestern U.S. is about to feel the wrath of a punishing heat wave that includes a forecast of 120 degrees in Phoenix _ a temperature not seen in the desert city in more than 20 years
10:30AM ( 13 minutes ago )
Shootings kill or injure at least 19 US children each day
Shootings kill or injure at least 19 U.S. children each day, with boys, teenagers and blacks most at risk, according to a government study that paints a bleak portrait of persistent violence
9:54AM ( 49 minutes ago )
U.S. News
The Latest: 6 Central Europe nations vow unity on migration
Defense officials of six Central European countries and the Balkans have pledged close cooperation in tackling migration with all possible means including use of armed forces
10:10AM ( 34 minutes ago )
Prosecutors want German nationalist's immunity lifted
Prosecutors want a German nationalist party leader's immunity lifted so that they can pursue an investigation of allegations that she lied under oath
9:59AM ( 44 minutes ago )
Russia warns US after downing of Syrian warplane
Russia says it will track U.S.-led coalition planes operating in Syria west of the Euphrates River as potential targets after the U.S. military shot down a Syrian air force jet
9:58AM ( 45 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Lonzo Ball's draft stock stays strong with Lakers watching
By now the entire basketball world knows Lonzo Ball is a singular talent with a unique parent
9:40AM ( 1 hour ago )
10 Things to Know for Today
Among 10 Things to Know: Suspect detained after vehicle hits pedestrians near London mosque; Japan looks at lapse in reporting of collision between U.S. Navy ship an merchant vessel.
6:02AM ( 4 hours ago )
Long road: Koepka's journey now includes a US Open title
The list of places Brooks Koepka had to go to win golf tournaments looks like a page straight out of a travelogue
2:14AM ( 8 hours ago )
AP Sports
Clippers, city of Inglewood negotiate on proposed new arena
The Inglewood City Council unanimously approved an exclusive negotiating agreement with the Los Angeles Clippers that could lead to building an arena for the NBA team across the street from the future home of the NFL's Chargers and Rams
9:23PM ( 3 days ago )
New Clippers arena gets backing from Inglewood City Council
The Inglewood City Council unanimously approved an exclusive negotiating agreement with the Los Angeles Clippers that could lead to building an arena for the NBA team across the street from the future home of the NFL's Chargers and Rams
2:43PM ( 3 days ago )
Oakland triumphant as parade set to celebrate NBA's Warriors
They are called the Golden State Warriors, but they don't belong to all of California. The down-on-its-luck city that always takes a back seat to San Francisco gets to celebrate Thursday in a parade and rally for the hometown team and its NBA title.
12:40PM ( 3 days ago )
AP Online Football
Justices take on fight over partisan electoral maps
The Supreme Court is wading into the thicket of partisan redistricting in a case from Wisconsin
9:48AM ( 56 minutes ago )
France's Macron to reshuffle govt after huge parliament win
French President Emmanuel Macron is set to rearrange his Cabinet after his new centrist party swept parliamentary elections
9:39AM ( 1 hour ago )
Confirmation of Serbia's first gay premier thrown into doubt
The ruling conservatives say that if Serbia's Prime Minister-designate Ana Brnabic does not get enough votes to be confirmed by parliament as the first openly gay person to head the country's government, early general elections would be held
8:45AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
The Latest: Trump attends Gorsuch Supreme Court ceremony
President Donald Trump has visited the Supreme Court for the ceremonial swearing-in of new Justice Neil Gorsuch
2:53PM ( 3 days ago )
Another skid for tech companies sends US stocks lower
US stocks skid as technology companies, retailers and smaller companies take steep losses.
12:34PM ( 3 days ago )
Reports say Mueller probe now examining possible obstruction
The scope of the Russia investigation now in the hands of a special counsel might be widening
7:36AM ( 4 days ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
Kelly presses 'Infowars' host Jones on Sandy Hook denial
Pressed repeatedly by Megyn Kelly to admit he was wrong to call the shooting at Newton, Connecticut a hoax, Alex Jones hemmed and hawed
7:39PM ( 15 hours ago )
Prada takes inspiration from graphic novels for Milan show
Miuccia Prada took inspiration from graphic novels for her latest collection, which aims to create a dialogue between the virtual world and the real world.
7:07PM ( 15 hours ago )
Cosby team triumphant, but sex crime retrial, lawsuits loom
Legal experts say prosecutors in Bill Cosby's sexual assault case are likely to reshape their case for the second trial.
6:57PM ( 15 hours ago )
AP Entertainment
Blondie's Debbie Harry reigns over NYC's Mermaid Parade
Debbie Harry and Chris Stein of the new wave band Blondie reigned over a waterlogged edition of New York City's zany Mermaid Parade
7:09PM ( 1 day ago )
McCartney, Rowling promoted in the queen's Birthday Honors
Paul McCartney and JK Rowling just got promoted, so to speak, in Britain's hierarchy
10:55AM ( 1 day ago )
Monterey Pop celebrates 50th with Eric Burdon, Norah Jones
The Monterey International Pop Festival is celebrating its 50th anniversary with another three-day concert that's bringing back a few acts from a half century ago
9:22PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Online Recordings News
A look at what is ahead now that Brexit talks have started
It took as good as a year, but the talks on Britain's exit from the European Union finally started Monday. Here is what is at stake.
8:59AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Interview: Qatar Airways CEO warns of 'lasting wound'
The CEO of Qatar Airways says the blockade imposed on his country by its Gulf neighbors "will leave a lasting wound."
8:52AM ( 1 hour ago )
Religious, indigenous leaders demand rainforests be saved
Religious, indigenous leaders call for end to deforestation in an international multi-faith and multi-cultural plea to reduce emissions that fuel climate change that is killing tropical rainforests
8:48AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Jets' Forte on those who think team is tanking: 'Bring it'
New York Jets running back Matt Forte dismisses the notion by some fans and media that the team is trying to tank this season to get a high draft pick next year
7:18PM ( 4 days ago )
Terrell Davis' visit with Broncos brings back memories
Terrell Davis has visited the Denver Broncos headquarters for the first time since being elected to the Pro Football Hall of Fame
6:54PM ( 4 days ago )
Chargers say bittersweet farewells in last week in San Diego
The Chargers are down to their final days in San Diego
8:30PM ( 5 days ago )
AP Sports - NFL
Sizzling heat wave creates health hazard in southwestern US
The Southwestern U.S. is about to feel the wrath of a punishing heat wave that includes a forecast of 120 degrees in Phoenix _ a temperature not seen in the desert city in more than 20 years
10:30AM ( 13 minutes ago )
Shootings kill or injure at least 19 US children each day
Shootings kill or injure at least 19 U.S. children each day, with boys, teenagers and blacks most at risk, according to a government study that paints a bleak portrait of persistent violence
9:54AM ( 49 minutes ago )
FBI missed rigged jackpot in 2006 before lottery scheme grew
A 2006 FBI inquiry has emerged as a missed opportunity to stop a jackpot rigging scandal that corrupted the nation's $70 billion lottery industry for years while enriching a tiny group of insiders
7:33AM ( 3 hours ago )
To post or not to post: Internet tips for college hopefuls
High schools and colleges offer tips on the role of social media in the admissions process
4:06AM ( 6 hours ago )
Harvard students' ouster over offensive posts stirs debate
Harvard University's recent decision to rescind admission offers to 10 incoming freshmen because of offensive Facebook posts is drawing attention from far beyond the Ivy League school's halls
4:00AM ( 6 hours ago )