Wednesday May 23rd, 2018 12:28PM

Prospect of NAFTA rewrite gives US farmers a case of jitters

By The Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) — A sizable majority of rural Americans backed Donald Trump's presidential bid, drawn to his calls to slash environmental rules, strengthen law enforcement and replace the federal health care law.

But many farmers are nervous about another plank in Trump's agenda: His vow to overhaul U.S. trade policy, including his intent announced Thursday to renegotiate the North American Free Trade Agreement with Canada and Mexico.

Trump's message that NAFTA was a job-killing disaster had never resonated much in rural America. NAFTA had widened access to Mexican and Canadian markets, boosting U.S. farm exports and benefiting many farmers.

Farm Country went on red alert last month when it looked as if Trump wasn't even going to pursue a NAFTA rewrite: White House aides had spread the word that the president would simply withdraw from the pact.

"Mr. President, America's corn farmers helped elect you," Wesley Spurlock of the National Corn Growers Association warned in a statement. "Withdrawing from NAFTA would be disastrous for American agriculture."

Within hours, Trump softened his stance. He wouldn't actually dump NAFTA, he said. He'd first try to forge a more advantageous deal with Mexico and Canada — a move that formally began Thursday when his top trade negotiator, Robert Lighthizer, informed Congress of the administration's intent to renegotiate NAFTA.

As a candidate, Trump defined his "America First" stance as a means to fight unfair foreign competition. He blamed unjust deals for swelling U.S. trade gaps and stealing factory jobs.

But NAFTA and other deals have been good for American farmers, who stand to lose if Trump ditches the pact or ignites a trade war. The United States has enjoyed a trade surplus in farm products since at least 1967, government data show. Last year, farm exports exceeded imports by $20.5 billion.

"You don't start off trade negotiations ... by picking fights with your trade partners that are completely unnecessary," says Aaron Lehman, a fifth-generation Iowa farmer who produces corn, soybeans, oats and hay.

Many farmers worry that Trump's policies will jeopardize their exports just as they face weaker crop and livestock prices.

"It comes up pretty quickly in conversation," says Blake Hurst, a corn and soybean farmer in northwestern Missouri's Atchison County.

That county's voters backed Trump more than 3-to-1 in the election but now feel "it would be better if the rhetoric (on trade) was a little less strident," says Hurst, president of the Missouri Farm Bureau.

Trump's main argument against NAFTA and other pacts was that they exposed American workers to unequal competition with low-wage workers in countries like Mexico and China.

NAFTA did lead some American manufacturers to move factories and jobs to Mexico. But since it took effect in 1994 and eased tariffs, annual farm exports to Mexico have jumped nearly five-fold to about $18 billion. Mexico is the No. 3 market for U.S. agriculture, notably corn, soybeans and pork.

"The trade agreements that we've had have been very beneficial," says Stephen Censky, CEO of the American Soybean Association. "We need to take care not to blow the significant gains that agriculture has won."

The U.S. has run a surplus in farm trade with Mexico for 20 of the 23 years since NAFTA took effect. Still, the surpluses with Mexico became deficits in 2015 and 2016 as global livestock and grain prices plummeted and shrank the value of American exports, notes Joseph Glauber of the International Food Policy Research Institute.

Mexico has begun to seek alternatives to U.S. food because, as its agriculture secretary, Jose Calzada Rovirosa, said in March, Trump's remarks on trade "have injected uncertainty" into the agriculture business.

Once word had surfaced that Trump was considering pulling out of NAFTA, Sonny Perdue, two days into his job as the president's agriculture secretary, hastened to the White House with a map showing areas that would be hurt most by a pullout, overlapped with many that voted for Trump.

"I tried to demonstrate to him that in the agricultural market, sometimes words like 'withdraw' or 'terminate' can have a major impact on markets," Perdue said in an interview with The Associated Press. "I think the president made a very wise decision for the benefit of many agricultural producers across the country" by choosing to remain in NAFTA.

Trump delivered another disappointment for U.S. farm groups in January by fulfilling a pledge to abandon the Trans-Pacific Partnership, which the Obama administration negotiated with 11 Asia-Pacific countries. Trump argued that the pact would cost Americans jobs by pitting them against low-wage Asian labor.

But the deal would have given U.S. farmers broader access to Japan's notoriously impregnable market and easier entry into fast-growing Vietnam. Philip Seng of the U.S. Meat Export Federation notes that the U.S. withdrawal from TPP left Australia with a competitive advantage because it had already negotiated lower tariffs in Japan.

Trump has also threatened to impose tariffs on Chinese and Mexican imports, thereby raising fears that those trading partners would retaliate with their own sanctions.

Farmers know they're frequently the first casualties of trade wars. Many recall a 2009 trade rift in which China responded to U.S. tire tariffs by imposing tariffs on U.S. chicken parts. And Mexico slapped tariffs on U.S. goods ranging from ham to onions to Christmas trees in 2009 to protest a ban on Mexican trucks crossing the border.

The White House declined to comment on farmers' fears that Trump's trade policy stands to hurt them. But officials say they've sought to ease concerns, by, for example, having Agriculture Secretary Perdue announce a new undersecretary to oversee trade and foreign agricultural affairs.

Many farmers are still hopeful about the Trump administration. Some, for example, applaud his plans to slash environmental rules that they say inflate the cost of running a farm. Some also hold out hope that the author of "The Art of the Deal" will negotiate ways to improve NAFTA.

One such way might involve Canada. NAFTA let Canada shield its dairy farmers from foreign competition behind tariffs and regulations but left at least one exception — an American ultra-filtered milk used in cheese. When Canadian farmers complained about the cheaper imports, Canada changed its policy and effectively priced ultra-filtered American milk out of the market.

"Canada has made business for our dairy farmers in Wisconsin and other border states very difficult," Trump tweeted last month. "We will not stand for this. Watch!"

Some U.S. cattle producers would also like a renegotiated NAFTA to give them something the current version doesn't: The right to label their product "Made in America." In 2015, the World Trade Organization struck down the United States' country-of-origin labeling rules as unfair to Mexico and Canada.

Many still worry that Trump's planned overhaul of American trade policy is built to revive manufacturing and that farming remains an afterthought.

"So much of the conversation in the campaign had been in Detroit or in Indiana" and focused on manufacturing jobs, said Kathy Baylis, an economist at the University of Illinois. The importance of American farm exports "never made it into the rhetoric."


AP Writers David Pitt in Des Moines and Mary Clare Jalonick in Washington contributed to this report.


Follow Paul Wiseman on Twitter at https://twitter.com/PaulWisemanAP

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP World News, AP Business, AP Business - Economy, AP Business - Financial Markets, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Agriculture
© Copyright 2018 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Justice official says he stands by critical memo on Comey
Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein has told members of Congress that he stands by a memo he wrote that the White House has cited as justification for the firing last week of FBI Director James Comey
12:57PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Prosecutors: Times Square driver wanted to 'kill them all'
Prosecutors say a man who mowed down a crowd of Times Square pedestrians with his car claimed he wanted to "kill them all" and that police should have shot him to stop him
12:52PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Ex-US Rep. Anthony Weiner pleads guilty in sexting case
Former congressman Anthony Weiner has pleaded guilty to transmitting sexual material to a minor, tearfully apologizing in a packed courtroom.
12:51PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
WikiLeaks' Assange calls end of rape case important victory
Sweden's top prosecutor is dropping an investigation into a rape claim against WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange after almost seven years but is not making a determination of guilt or innocence
12:33PM ( 35 minutes ago )
Brazil president fights for job amid calls for him to go
Brazilian President Michel Temer is fighting to keep his job amid calls for him to resign because of a recording that allegedly captures him endorsing hush money for an ex-lawmaker
12:10PM ( 58 minutes ago )
Terror suspect harshly interrogated by CIA won't testify
The first CIA captive subjected to harsh interrogation after 9/11 has made a last-minute decision not to testify about conditions inside the Guantanamo Bay detention center
12:02PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Russians increasingly indifferent to Trump, US turmoil
While their country has become a daily source of headlines and political intrigue in the United States, most Russians are watching the drama over President Donald Trump's relationship with Moscow with resignation, even indifference
10:55AM ( 2 hours ago )
Trump, dogged by questions at home, makes first trip abroad
President Donald Trump is about to embark on his maiden foreign trip to the Middle East and Europe
10:33AM ( 2 hours ago )
Ex-US Rep. Anthony Weiner to plead guilty in sexting case
A law enforcement official says former U.S. Rep. Anthony Weiner has agreed to plead guilty to a charge of transferring obscene material to a minor
10:10AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Illinois to change sex-abuse law with help of Hastert victim
Illinois is set to eliminate the statute of limitations in child sex abuse cases through legislation passed with support from a victim of imprisoned former U.S. Rep. Dennis Hastert
12:25PM ( 42 minutes ago )
Green Machine is back, Deere posts a big 1Q and ups outlook
Deere shares hit new heights on a strong quarter and an even stronger outlook
11:57AM ( 1 hour ago )
Standard & Poor's raises Indonesia credit rating
Standard & Poor's has raised Indonesia's sovereign credit rating to investment grade in recognition of a more stable political environment and improved control over government finances
10:02AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Business
China's Xi says willing to help end rift with South Korea
Chinese President Xi Jinping has said he's willing to help ties with South Korea return to a "normal track" amid a rift over Seoul's deployment of a high-tech U.S. missile-defense system to guard against North Korean threats
4:55AM ( 8 hours ago )
Global shares mostly higher on Wall Street despite worries
Global stocks are meandering but mostly higher, following an overnight recovery on Wall Street, though investor optimism was tempered by U.S. political uncertainties and a crisis brewing in Brazil
4:13AM ( 8 hours ago )
Draft a sign of progress on South China Sea code of conduct
Analysts say a framework agreement between China and ASEAN menbers on a code of conduct in the South China Sea marks a potentially significant step toward cooling tensions in the strategic waterway
3:52AM ( 9 hours ago )
AP Business - Economy
Stocks bounce back after Trump-related losses
Global stocks are meandering but mostly higher, following an overnight recovery on Wall Street, though investor optimism was tempered by U.S. political uncertainties and a crisis brewing in Brazil
7:54AM ( 5 hours ago )
Asian shares mixed as Trump, Brazil worries simmer
Asian stocks are mixed as investors fret over the U.S. political situation and a crisis brewing in Brazil.
1:40AM ( 11 hours ago )
Brazil's president may lead a 'walking dead administration'
Brazilian President Michel Temer is defiantly promising to remain in power despite a damaging new corruption allegation, but Latin America's largest nation could very well be rudderless as long as he stays leading a "walking dead administration."
12:04AM ( 13 hours ago )
AP Business - Financial Markets
China, Japan extract combustible ice from seafloor
Commercial development of the globe's vast reserves of a frozen fossil fuel known as "combustible ice" has moved closer to reality after Japan and China successfully extracted the material from the seafloor
5:48AM ( 7 hours ago )
Toyota, Nissan, others get behind fuel cell push in Japan
Japan backs push for pollution-free vehicles that run on hydrogen, plans to build more hydrogen fueling stations and boost number of fuel-cell vehicles on roads to 40,000 by 2020
2:31AM ( 10 hours ago )
Saudi Arabia working to dazzle Trump in busy overseas visit
Saudi Arabia is making every effort to dazzle and impress President Donald Trump on his first overseas trip
11:42AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Industries
Idaho asks appeals court to uphold ban on spying at farms
Idaho wants a federal appeals court to reinstate its ban on spying at farms, dairies and slaughterhouses
2:41PM ( 6 days ago )
China, US reach agreement on beef, poultry and natural gas
China and US reach agreement on beef, poultry and liquefied natural gas
5:25AM ( 1 week ago )
Star-crossed salmon survive spillway's erosion but suffocate
Officials say a quarter-million hatchery salmon survived the near-collapse of a California dam's spillway this winter, only to suffocate after a pump failed this week
9:26PM ( 1 week ago )
AP Business - Agriculture
Justice official says he stands by critical memo on Comey
Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein has told members of Congress that he stands by a memo he wrote that the White House has cited as justification for the firing last week of FBI Director James Comey
12:57PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Prosecutors: Times Square driver wanted to 'kill them all'
Prosecutors say a man who mowed down a crowd of Times Square pedestrians with his car claimed he wanted to "kill them all" and that police should have shot him to stop him
12:52PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Sweden drops case but WikiLeaks' Assange is not in the clear
Swedish prosecutors have dropped their investigation into a rape allegation against Julian Assange, almost seven years after it began and five years after the WikiLeaks founder sought refuge inside Ecuador's London embassy to avoid extradition
12:50PM ( 18 minutes ago )
The Latest: Anthony Weiner cries while apologizing in court
Former U.S. Rep. Anthony Weiner is crying in court as he apologizes to the 15-year-old girl with whom he exchanged sexually explicit texts
12:42PM ( 26 minutes ago )
Family of musician Chris Cornell disputes he killed himself
The family of musician Chris Cornell is disputing a medical examiner's finding that the Soundgarden frontman killed himself after performing in Detroit
12:40PM ( 27 minutes ago )