clear
Monday December 11th, 2017 11:46PM

AP Exclusive: Warning, escape route lack by California dam

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

Communities just downstream of California's Lake Oroville dam would not receive adequate warning or time for evacuations if the 770-foot-tall dam itself — rather than its spillways — were to abruptly fail, the state water agency that operates the nation's tallest dam repeatedly advised federal regulators a half-decade ago.

The state Department of Water Resources informed federal dam regulators that local emergency officials "do not believe there is enough time to perform evacuations in the communities immediately downstream of the dam during a sudden failure," according to a Feb. 8, 2011, letter reviewed by The Associated Press.

Absent "significant" advance warning, emergency responders instead would likely withdraw to safer ground and prepare for victims, said the same letter by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, which oversees safety of hydroelectric dams, in a summary of the state's conclusions.

The catastrophic scenario of a sudden breach at California's second-largest water reservoir, outlined between 2010 and 2012 in online archives of federal dam regulators, is a different and far graver situation than the concern that prompted sudden evacuation orders Sunday for 188,000 downstream residents.

In an email Thursday, state water agency spokesman Ed Wilson said that despite the repeated back-and-forth correspondence by state and federal officials about reducing detection- and response time to allow for evacuations downstream in the event of Oroville dam's sudden failure, the scenario was "hypothetical" and "not how dams typically fail in real life."

Late Sunday afternoon, operators of the nearly half-century-old dam in California's Sierra Nevada foothills became alarmed that the water cascading from the reservoir after a series of winter storms could roar uncontrolled down a rapidly eroding emergency spillway toward towns downstream. They ordered residents of parts of three counties to leave.

Despite the troubles with the dam's flood-control spillways, authorities have stressed that they do not believe the dam itself is threatened. Sunday's precautionary evacuation order was eased by mid-week to allow people to return to the 16,000-resident town of Oroville and other communities.

The federal-state discussion about the worst-case scenario over the years highlights steps that California's water agency and others still should take to do more to improve warning and escape for people downstream, say local officials and a Florida-based evacuation expert.

Those measures include widening the entirety of a mixed two- and four-lane state highway leading away from Oroville and other communities and doing more to improve public-warning systems. The federal dam regulators also called for annual "public education...that describes what residents should do during an emergency" at the dam.

As it was, some families who leaped into their cars to flee on Sunday found themselves caught in traffic jams hours later in the path of potential danger.

"People were just panicking," said Nancy Borsdorf of Oroville, who grabbed two Bibles and a Christian-music CD to take with her after friends phoned to urge her to go. "'Get out of town, the dam is going to blow.'"

Many public officials and ordinary people rushed to help direct traffic or to settle the evacuees streaming into shelters. But evacuees also described seeing families abandoning cars, and even watching fistfights on gridlocked roads.

The federal government in recent years has made evacuation and emergency-response plans for major dams off-limit information for the public, for fear details could be exploited for terror attacks or hacking. California officials cited that reason this week in declining to release the latest emergency plans for the dam.

Wilson, the state Department of Water Resources spokesman, said authorities have implemented the reverse-911 automated warnings recommended by federal regulators, and also activated an emergency broadcast system locally. Residents confirmed the reverse-911 system worked Sunday.

With the arrival Thursday of a new wave of storms, and months left in the rainy season, state spokesperson Nancy Vogel said California now has drones, cameras and human lookouts watching the dam and its spillways.

Operators have been releasing torrents of water down the damaged main spillway to try to make sure the water does not pour over the emergency spillway as it did last weekend.

Even with round-the-clock efforts by dam operators, Oroville Mayor Linda Dahlmeier immediately began praying for those closer to the dam when she heard the first drops of rain hit the metal roof of her home Thursday.

"You just start bawling," Dahlmeier said. "This is Mother Nature's hand."

Oroville used to have civil-defense sirens for emergencies, Dahlmeier thought, but funds for such public expenses have dwindled in the foothill counties. Neither she nor others recalled the annual safety briefings for the public that federal regulators urged of the state water agency.

"You know what the evacuation plan is? 'Get the hell out of town!'" said Kevin Zeitler, a critic of the state water agency's interactions with communities downstream of the dam.

Zeitler was staying put at his office in Oroville's vulnerable downtown, but keeping his pickup truck out front fully packed.

Since the 1990s, Oroville and other communities in Butte County have asked the state for the $300 million it would take to widen the full route of a key highway out of the county from two lanes to four, said Jon Clark, head of the Butte County Association of Governments.

Unquestionably, that would have helped in the evacuations, Clark and others said.

For Butte County's many low-income retirees and others unable to drive, Clark's association got buses on the road Sunday to carry people to safety.

In a disaster as sudden as a major problem with a dam, authorities will have had warning signs telling them to increase their vigilance, even if that is just forecasts of storms coming, said John Renne, an urban-planning professor at Florida Atlantic University.

And the public can almost always be warned, even if it entails greater government investment in public-warning technology. "Minutes can save lives," Renne said.

___

Associated Press writers Don Thompson in Sacramento and Tim Reiterman in San Francisco contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines
© Copyright 2017 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
The Latest: No sprinklers in Hawaii high-rise where 3 died
Honolulu's mayor says the burning high-rise where at least three people have died was not equipped with sprinklers
1:00AM ( 41 minutes ago )
3 dead in fire in Honolulu high-rise apartment building
At least three people died in a fire that broke out on the 26th floor of a Honolulu high-rise Friday and hundreds fled as smoke billowed from the upper floors of the giant apartment complex.
12:39AM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Fire official: At least 3 dead in high-rise fire
Honolulu Emergency Medical Services have treated two patients and transported them in serious and stable condition to the hospital.
11:20PM ( 2 hours ago )
U.S. News
Disney fans get look at 'Incredibles 2,' 'Wreck-It Ralph 2'
Disney fans get look at 'Incredibles 2,' 'Wreck-It Ralph 2' at fan expo
1:33AM ( 9 minutes ago )
Allowed in by Trump, Afghan girls robotics team lands in DC
An all-girls robotics team from Afghanistan have arrived in Washington following a last-minute intervention by President Donald Trump
12:15AM ( 1 hour ago )
Puig hits 3-run homer in 9th to help Dodgers beat Miami 6-4
Yasiel Puig hit his second homer of the game with two out in the ninth inning, and the three-run shot helped the Los Angeles Dodgers beat Miami 6-4 for their seventh consecutive victory
11:22PM ( 2 hours ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Fire rages in Honolulu high-rise apartment building
More than 60 firefighters are battling fire in a Honolulu high-rise apartment building
10:36PM ( 3 hours ago )
Growing sinkhole swallows 2 houses, 1 boat in Florida
A sinkhole in Florida swallowed a boat, destroyed two houses and prompted officials to evacuate residents from about a dozen homes Friday
10:33PM ( 3 hours ago )
China cremates body of jailed Nobel laureate Liu Xiaobo
China cremates the body of imprisoned Nobel Peace Prize laureate Liu Xiaobo amid international criticism of Beijing for not letting him travel abroad as he had wished
10:12PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP National News
Russian-American lobbyist joined Trump's son's meeting, too
A Russian-American lobbyist says he attended a June 2016 meeting with President Donald Trump's son that was billed as part of a Russian government effort to help the Republican campaign
6:49PM ( 6 hours ago )
Papers reveal pot dealer's grisly confession in 4 slayings
Court papers show a marijuana dealer gave police a grisly account of killing four men on his family's Pennsylvania farm, crushing one of them with a backhoe after shooting him and trying to set three of the bodies on fire in a metal bin
6:47PM ( 6 hours ago )
Ick-free and ready for a dip: Portland touts revived river
Portland, Oregon, is known as an eco-conscious city, but the same reputation didn't apply to the sewage-fouled river that flows through it
6:22PM ( 7 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Federal ranger's testimony sought in Steinle murder trial
A federal agency is blocking efforts to compel a federal ranger whose stolen gun was used to kill a woman on a San Francisco pier to testify at the suspect's murder trial
7:59PM ( 5 hours ago )
Nevada pot retailers get supply relief, but not out of woods
Regulators took steps this week to make sure Nevada's fledgling but popular marijuana industry doesn't run out of pot to sell, but another legal roadblock may be looming
7:15PM ( 6 hours ago )
Patrol vehicle collides with garbage truck, killing trooper
Authorities say a marked patrol vehicle collided with a garbage truck, killing one state trooper and leaving his partner with a concussion in western Pennsylvania
5:02PM ( 8 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Papers reveals grisly confession in 4 Pennsylvania slayings
A pot dealer gave police a grisly account of killing four men on his family's Pennsylvania farm, crushing one of them with a backhoe and trying to set three of the bodies on fire in the same metal bin, according to court papers
3:47PM ( 9 hours ago )
Liberation from militants leaves devastation in Mosul
The 9-month fight to defeat the Islamic State group in Mosul ended in a crescendo of devastation: bombardment that damaged or destroyed a third of its historic Old City in just three weeks
3:21PM ( 10 hours ago )
Egypt attacks: 2 German female tourists, 5 policemen killed
Attacker stabs foreign tourists in Egyptian resort, killing 2 German women; 5 policemen killed outside of Cairo
3:11PM ( 10 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
The Latest: No sprinklers in Hawaii high-rise where 3 died
Honolulu's mayor says the burning high-rise where at least three people have died was not equipped with sprinklers
1:00AM ( 42 minutes ago )
3 dead in fire in Honolulu high-rise apartment building
At least three people died in a fire that broke out on the 26th floor of a Honolulu high-rise Friday and hundreds fled as smoke billowed from the upper floors of the giant apartment complex.
12:39AM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Fire official: At least 3 dead in high-rise fire
Honolulu Emergency Medical Services have treated two patients and transported them in serious and stable condition to the hospital.
11:20PM ( 2 hours ago )
Fire rages in Honolulu high-rise apartment building
More than 60 firefighters are battling fire in a Honolulu high-rise apartment building
10:36PM ( 3 hours ago )
Growing sinkhole swallows 2 houses, 1 boat in Florida
A sinkhole in Florida swallowed a boat, destroyed two houses and prompted officials to evacuate residents from about a dozen homes Friday
10:33PM ( 3 hours ago )