clear
Wednesday December 13th, 2017 3:51PM

Patagonia joins lawsuits challenging Trump's monument plans

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

SALT LAKE CITY (AP) — Outdoor retailing giant Patagonia on Wednesday joined a flurry of lawsuits challenging President Donald Trump's decision to chop up two large national monuments in Utah could finally bring an answer to the much-debated question of whether presidents have the legal authority to undo or change monuments created by past presidents.

Until that question is answered months or years from now, the fate of the contested lands in Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante national monuments will remain unresolved.

Proclamations signed Monday by the president allow lands no longer protected as a national monument to be opened up in 60 days to mining, but conservation and tribal groups will likely try to keep that from happening.

Mark Squillace, professor of natural resources law at the University of Colorado-Boulder, said he doubts the federal government would permit mining so quickly after Trump's announcement because it would be bad politics, especially as the legal battle mushrooms.

California-based Patagonia filed its lawsuit on behalf of several other organizations to block Trump's reductions to Bears Ears. The California-based company said in the lawsuit that Trump's proclamation shrinking the monument by 85 percent exceeds the president's authority and strips much-needed protections from sacred tribal lands.

Patagonia also replaced its usual home page with a stark message, "The President Stole Your Land."

The post drew a strong rebuke from Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke who called it "nefarious, false and a lie."

Three lawsuits already had been filed involving Utah's monuments. And more are expected — especially if Trump follows Zinke's recommendations to shrink two other monuments — Gold Butte in Nevada and Cascade Siskiyou in Oregon.

Supporters of Trump's move welcomed the fight, saying it will answer longstanding questions about presidential power involving the protection of land.

"Hopefully, we can have some closure on what the president can and cannot do," said Mike Noel, a Republican state representative in Utah who was on stage with the president during his proclamation signing in Salt Lake City.

Past presidents have trimmed national monuments and redrawn their boundaries 18 times, according to the National Park Service.

Legal experts disagree on whether the 1906 Antiquities Act — allowing presidents to create a monument — also lets them reduce one.

The question has never been settled in court, but conservation and paleontology groups and Native American tribes launching lawsuits are preparing to argue that Trump doesn't have that authority and his move jeopardizes a wealth of Native American artifacts, dinosaur fossils and rugged spaces.

"Gee whiz, it sounds like there are going to be a lot of attorneys making a whole lot of money," quipped Noel. "For every organization, there's a lunch ticket for a group of attorneys to exist."

Noel plans to intervene himself, filing a court brief to show support for the president's actions.

Donald Kochan, a professor of natural resources, property and administrative law at Chapman University in Orange, California, believes Trump's action is likely legal and the separate lawsuits allow each group to show supporters they're speaking up.

Squillace said the lawsuits will likely be merged into one case for each monument.

He thinks a court will try to focus on the overall question of whether Trump has the authority to reduce the monuments — something Squillace doesn't think the president has the legal authority to do.

While the legal battles play out, Utah Republican Rep. Rob Bishop, chairman of the House Natural Resources Committee, has introduced a bill that would prevent presidents from designating monuments larger than 85,000 acres and give states and local officials the power to veto a monument larger than 10,000 acres.

Bishop's bill is awaiting a vote on the House floor.

___

Associated Press writer Matthew Daly in Washington contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News
© Copyright 2017 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Wildfire destroys mobile homes in California retirement park
A brush fire driven by gusty winds that have plagued Southern California all week exploded rapidly Thursday and destroyed dozens of trailer homes in a retirement community north of San Diego
9:51PM ( 5 minutes ago )
Pearl Harbor survivors in their 90s attend solemn ceremony
Survivors have gathered at the site of the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor to remember fellow servicemen killed in the early morning raid 76 years ago
9:48PM ( 8 minutes ago )
The Latest: 439 buildings burned in fire northwest of LA
Fire officials say at least 439 homes and other buildings have burned in a wildfire northeast of Los Angeles
9:29PM ( 27 minutes ago )
U.S. News
Marlins' Dee Gordon traded to Mariners for 3 prospects
Miami second baseman Dee Gordon has been traded to the Seattle Mariners for three prospects in a deal that marks the start of the Marlins' latest payroll purge, this time under new CEO Derek Jeter
9:21PM ( 35 minutes ago )
76ers agree trade Jahil Okafor, 2nd-round pick to Brooklyn
The Philadelphia 76ers traded beleaguered center Jahlil Okafor to the Brooklyn Nets
9:03PM ( 52 minutes ago )
Longtime Washington state medical marijuana activist dies
JoAnna McKee, a pioneering medical marijuana activist in Washington state, has died at age 74
8:59PM ( 57 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
US team still planning for Olympics despite confusion
US Team still planning for Olympics in Korea despite doubts brought on by Trump administration
7:30PM ( 2 hours ago )
Combative Franken quits, points to GOP tolerance of Trump
Sen. Al Franken has announced he's resigning from the Senate, but not without taking a shot at the GOP for tolerating President Trump
7:24PM ( 2 hours ago )
After cyberattack, much of county's business done on paper
North Carolina's largest metro area was discovering Thursday just how hard it is to conduct business without county computers that handle a wide range of transactions, a day after local leaders refused to pay hackers who froze their system
6:45PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP National News
Streep calls out Harvey Weinstein at women's conference
Meryl Streep says she and other actresses are planning to make a series of "non-negotiable" demands in the wake of the sexual harassment and assault allegations that have rocked Hollywood and America media and politics
5:42PM ( 4 hours ago )
14 states sue to allege US failure to enforce smog rules
Fourteen states and the District of Columbia are suing the Trump administration over what they say is a failure to enforce smog standards
5:31PM ( 4 hours ago )
Iowa teen says mom refused to help sister before she starved
An Iowa teenager testified that his mother forced him and his two sisters to sleep on their bedroom floor in their own waste for months and that she refused to feed one sister in the days before she starved to death
5:18PM ( 4 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Interior delays Obama-era regulation on methane emissions
The Interior Department is delaying an Obama-era regulation aimed at restricting harmful methane emissions from oil and gas production on federal lands
8:14PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Franken steps down, takes shot at Trump
Sen. Al Franken has reluctantly announced he's resigning from Congress, succumbing to a torrent of sexual harassment allegations
8:11PM ( 1 hour ago )
House ethics panel: Nunes didn't leak classified information
The House Ethics Committee has cleared the chairman of the House intelligence committee on a complaint that he may have leaked classified information
8:08PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Polish finance chief Morawiecki to be new prime minister
Poland's Prime Minister Beata Szydlo has resigned and will be replaced by Finance Minister Mateusz Morawiecki, the conservative ruling party announced on Thursday
5:52PM ( 4 hours ago )
The Latest: Lawmakers call meeting with Trump 'productive'
Republicans and Democratic leaders say they had a "productive" meeting Thursday with President Donald Trump on keeping the government running
5:51PM ( 4 hours ago )
House passes stopgap spending bill to avert weekend shutdown
The House has passed a stopgap spending bill to prevent a government shutdown this weekend and buy time for challenging talks on a wide range of unfinished business on Capitol Hill
5:47PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Bettman says NHL will consider Seattle expansion bid
NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman says the league's board of governors has agreed to consider an expansion application from Seattle
8:03PM ( 1 hour ago )
Poland: Time abroad, in finance seen as assets of PM nominee
Finance minister tapped to be Poland's next prime minister has economic and international experience seen as assets amid criticism from other European Union members
5:04PM ( 4 hours ago )
Prosecutors insist eye doc stole $136 million from Medicaid
Evidence proves a politically connected Florida eye doctor convicted of Medicare fraud stole more than $100 million, prosecutors said Thursday, countering an argument by the doctor's defense lawyers that he stole just $64,000
5:03PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Business
In the age of Amazon, Walmart is changing its legal name
Wal-Mart Stores Inc. is changing its legal name to reflect its shift away from physical stores
10:50PM ( 23 hours ago )
Patagonia joins lawsuits challenging Trump's monument plans
A flurry of lawsuits challenging President Donald Trump's decision to chop up two large national monuments in Utah could finally bring an answer to the much-debated question of whether presidents have the legal authority to undo or change monuments
9:32PM ( 1 day ago )
The Latest: Patagonia sues over Trump's monuments order
More lawsuits are expected Wednesday over the Trump administration's plans to shrink several national monuments.
8:36PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
Wildfire destroys mobile homes in California retirement park
A brush fire driven by gusty winds that have plagued Southern California all week exploded rapidly Thursday and destroyed dozens of trailer homes in a retirement community north of San Diego
9:51PM ( 6 minutes ago )
Pearl Harbor survivors in their 90s attend solemn ceremony
Survivors have gathered at the site of the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor to remember fellow servicemen killed in the early morning raid 76 years ago
9:48PM ( 9 minutes ago )
The Latest: 439 buildings burned in fire northwest of LA
Fire officials say at least 439 homes and other buildings have burned in a wildfire northeast of Los Angeles
9:29PM ( 28 minutes ago )
California sheriff: 'Screw-up' behind release of molester
A California sheriff says a "screw-up" led to the mistaken release of an inmate who had pleaded guilty to child molestation
8:56PM ( 1 hour ago )
'Not a drill': Students hid in classrooms as shooter kills 2
A shooter killed two classmates at a New Mexico high school as students hid in their classrooms or in closets
8:01PM ( 1 hour ago )