clear
Wednesday December 13th, 2017 7:33PM

Alternate juror: Steinle shooting jury was right to acquit

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — An alternate juror who sat through a murder trial in a case that sparked a fierce national debate on immigration said Wednesday he agreed with the jury's decision to acquit a Mexican man of murder in the shooting death of a San Francisco woman two years ago.

Phil Van Stockum, 33, said in an interview with The Associated Press that there was no evidence Jose Ines Garcia Zarate planned or meant to kill Kate Steinle in 2015.

Garcia Zarate said he found a gun wrapped in a T-shirt under a seat on a popular pier, and it fired when he picked it up.

The bullet ricocheted off a concrete walkway about 18 feet (5.5 meters) away and flew another 80 feet (24.4 meters) before striking Steinle in the back as she walked with her father and a family friend.

"The ricochet played into heavily whether he had the state of mind to commit murder," said Van Stockum, who didn't participate in jury deliberations.

Still, he sat through the entire trial and spoke with jurors after the verdict.

"I was not surprised by the verdict," he said.

Prosecutors charged Garcia Zarate with murder, arguing that he planned to kill somebody when he picked up the gun.

Van Stockum wrote an essay that Politico.com published Wednesday defending the verdict. He said he felt a need to explain it after President Donald Trump, Steinle's parents and many other commentators and social media users said they were disappointed with the decision.

"They appear to be confused by the verdict," Van Stockum said. "I was not confused."

Garcia Zarate had been deported five times before the shooting, and had been set free at the time of the shooting when the San Francisco sheriff's department ignored a federal immigration detainer request and released him after dropping an old marijuana charge.

San Francisco is sanctuary city and officials are limited in the cooperation they can give federal immigration authorities.

Van Stockum, a mechanical engineer, said he and other jurors were able to put aside their feelings about immigration and the news coverage the case received before the trial.

"The evidence did not show beyond a reasonable doubt he intended to kill anyone," Van Stockum said. "Politics had nothing to do with it."

Van Stockum said acquitting Garcia Zarate of involuntary manslaughter was a closer call. He said the jury instructions directed them to first determine if Garcia Zarate "brandished" the gun before it fired if they wanted to find him guilty of involuntary manslaughter.

He also said the evidence showed that a minuscule amount of gun powder was found on the hands of Garcia Zarate, supporting his claim that the gun was wrapped in a T-shirt when he picked it up and it fired.

Trump pointed to Steinle's death while campaigning for president as another reason why the United States should build a wall on it southern border and tighten immigration restrictions.

The jury did convict Garcia Zarate of being a felon in possession of handgun. His public defender Matt Gonzalez said he will ask a judge to toss out that conviction.

A federal grand jury in San Francisco indicted Garcia Zarate Tuesday on two gun and immigration charges. Gonzalez did not return a call seeking comment Wednesday.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines
© Copyright 2017 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Wildfire destroys mobile homes in California retirement park
A brush fire driven by gusty winds that have plagued Southern California all week exploded rapidly Thursday and destroyed dozens of trailer homes in a retirement community north of San Diego
9:51PM ( 9 minutes ago )
Pearl Harbor survivors in their 90s attend solemn ceremony
Survivors have gathered at the site of the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor to remember fellow servicemen killed in the early morning raid 76 years ago
9:48PM ( 11 minutes ago )
The Latest: 439 buildings burned in fire northwest of LA
Fire officials say at least 439 homes and other buildings have burned in a wildfire northeast of Los Angeles
9:29PM ( 30 minutes ago )
U.S. News
Brown out: Browns fire VP, coach Jackson keeps job for '18
Winless Browns fire top executive Sashi Brown, but coach Hue Jackson will be back in 2018 despite 1-27 record
9:57PM ( 3 minutes ago )
US team still planning for Olympics despite confusion
US Team still planning for Olympics in Korea despite doubts brought on by Trump administration
9:47PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Marlins' Dee Gordon traded to Mariners for 3 prospects
Miami second baseman Dee Gordon has been traded to the Seattle Mariners for three prospects in a deal that marks the start of the Marlins' latest payroll purge, this time under new CEO Derek Jeter
9:21PM ( 38 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
10 Things to Know for Friday
Among 10 Things to Know: Minnesota's Al Franken to quit Senate; House, Senate pass stopgap spending bill; unrest follows US decision to recognize Jerusalem as Israel's capital.
8:41PM ( 1 hour ago )
Combative Franken quits, points to GOP tolerance of Trump
Sen. Al Franken has announced he's resigning from the Senate, but not without taking a shot at the GOP for tolerating President Trump
7:24PM ( 2 hours ago )
After cyberattack, much of county's business done on paper
North Carolina's largest metro area was discovering Thursday just how hard it is to conduct business without county computers that handle a wide range of transactions, a day after local leaders refused to pay hackers who froze their system
6:45PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP National News
Streep calls out Harvey Weinstein at women's conference
Meryl Streep says she and other actresses are planning to make a series of "non-negotiable" demands in the wake of the sexual harassment and assault allegations that have rocked Hollywood and America media and politics
5:42PM ( 4 hours ago )
14 states sue to allege US failure to enforce smog rules
Fourteen states and the District of Columbia are suing the Trump administration over what they say is a failure to enforce smog standards
5:31PM ( 4 hours ago )
Iowa teen says mom refused to help sister before she starved
An Iowa teenager testified that his mother forced him and his two sisters to sleep on their bedroom floor in their own waste for months and that she refused to feed one sister in the days before she starved to death
5:18PM ( 4 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Wildfire destroys mobile homes in California retirement park
A brush fire driven by gusty winds that have plagued Southern California all week exploded rapidly Thursday and destroyed dozens of trailer homes in a retirement community north of San Diego
9:51PM ( 9 minutes ago )
Pearl Harbor survivors in their 90s attend solemn ceremony
Survivors have gathered at the site of the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor to remember fellow servicemen killed in the early morning raid 76 years ago
9:48PM ( 12 minutes ago )
The Latest: 439 buildings burned in fire northwest of LA
Fire officials say at least 439 homes and other buildings have burned in a wildfire northeast of Los Angeles
9:29PM ( 31 minutes ago )
California sheriff: 'Screw-up' behind release of molester
A California sheriff says a "screw-up" led to the mistaken release of an inmate who had pleaded guilty to child molestation
8:56PM ( 1 hour ago )
'Not a drill': Students hid in classrooms as shooter kills 2
A shooter killed two classmates at a New Mexico high school as students hid in their classrooms or in closets
8:01PM ( 1 hour ago )