clear
Monday December 11th, 2017 12:19PM

Travel ban faces scrutiny from judges who blocked it before

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

SEATTLE (AP) — Three federal appeals court judges who blocked President Donald Trump's second travel ban earlier this year had some skeptical questions about his third and latest set of restrictions on travelers from six mostly Muslim nations during oral arguments on Wednesday.

Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals Judges Ronald Gould, Richard Paez and Michael Hawkins heard arguments in Seattle on Hawaii's challenge to the ban.

The hearing came just two days after the U.S. Supreme Court announced that it was allowing the restrictions to go into effect at least until the 9th Circuit panel and their colleagues on the Richmond, Virginia-based 4th Circuit had a chance to rule on separate lawsuits against the ban.

Debate over the restrictions has centered on whether they constitute a legitimate exercise of national security powers or the "Muslim ban" Trump promised during his campaign.

But much of Wednesday's arguments focused on a narrower point: whether the president satisfied immigration law in issuing his latest travel order, which targets 150 million potential travelers from Chad, Iran, Libya, Somalia, Syria and Yemen.

In June, Gould, Paez and Hawkins blocked Trump's second travel ban, saying he had not made a required finding that the entry of people affected by that measure would be detrimental to U.S. interests.

Neal Katyal, the former U.S. solicitor general representing Hawaii, insisted that Trump had failed again and did not have authority to issue his latest travel restrictions.

"They have not made the findings this court called for," Katyal said. "They came back with zero."

Deputy Assistant Attorney General Hashim Mooppan noted that the government had conducted a 90-day, multi-agency review, after which Trump determined that certain countries do not provide enough information to sufficiently vet their citizens' backgrounds.

The ban is needed to keep out "foreign nationals about whom the United States Government lacks sufficient information to assess the risks they pose to the United States," the president said in his September proclamation announcing the latest travel restrictions.

"You might disagree with the finding, but you can't disagree that the finding was made," Mooppan said.

Hawaii Attorney General Douglas Chin said after the hearing that determining there's insufficient information to vet the foreigners is not the same as concluding their admission to the U.S. would be detrimental.

The government, he said, "didn't tell us why the existing system isn't working."

Citing national security concerns, Trump announced his initial travel ban on citizens of certain Muslim-majority nations in late January, bringing havoc and protests to airports around the country. A federal judge in Seattle soon blocked it, and courts since then have wrestled with the restrictions as the administration has rewritten them.

The latest version blocks travelers from the listed countries to varying degrees, allowing for students from some of the countries while blocking other business travelers and tourists, and allowing for admissions on a case-by-case basis. It also blocks travel by North Koreans along with some Venezuelan government officials and their families, although those parts of the restrictions are not at issue in the courts.

Mooppan argued that courts do not have the authority to consider claims that the president's actions violate federal immigration law, though he said it's conceivable courts could consider claims that the actions violate the constitution.

That assertion drew skeptical questioning from the judges, including a hypothetical from Gould: What if the president decided to bar anyone who's not a U.S. citizen?

Mooppan said even such a drastic action could not be reviewed by the courts unless Congress authorized them to do so.

Paez questioned the legitimacy of the administration's rationale for the restrictions, noting the exceptions for student visas: If those governments don't provide sufficient information, why allow anyone in?

Mooppan said the restrictions are carefully tailored to for each country, and designed in part to encourage them to be more forthcoming with the U.S. The exceptions also demonstrate the government is not engaged in banning Muslims, he said.

There was some discussion of the president's public statements concerning Muslims. Katyal noted that Trump continues to stoke anti-Islam sentiments. Last week he drew a sharp condemnation from British Prime Minister Theresa May's office when he retweeted a string of inflammatory videos from a fringe British political group purporting to show violence committed by Muslims.

Gould said the panel would rule "as soon as practical," noting the Supreme Court had suggested in its order this week that the appeals courts rule with appropriate urgency. Arguments are due to be held Friday before a full complement of 13 4th Circuit judges.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP World News
© Copyright 2017 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Travel ban faces scrutiny from judges who blocked it before
Judges from the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals will scrutinize President Donald Trump's travel ban after ruling against a previous version of the policy
3:40PM ( 8 minutes ago )
Son of slain black man wants life in prison for ex-officer
The youngest son of a black motorist who was shot to death by a white former police officer has asked a judge to sentence the ex-cop to life in prison
3:25PM ( 22 minutes ago )
Judge detains ricin suspect with prior suicide attempts
A federal judge says a woman accused of manufacturing ricin and testing the deadly toxin on fellow residents of a senior living facility in Vermont has a history of hospitalizations and suicide attempts
3:14PM ( 34 minutes ago )
U.S. News
The Latest: Senate barrel ahead on tax overhaul
The Senate's narrow GOP majority prevailed in a 51-47 vote to begin talks with House lawmakers on reconciling the two bills
3:39PM ( 8 minutes ago )
Health law sign-ups seen as falling short though more enroll
Health law sign-ups hit 3.6M, but shortened enrollment season means final tally likely to fall short
3:27PM ( 21 minutes ago )
Franken's support fades as Democrats call for resignation
Sen. Al Franken's support among his fellow Democrats is collapsing as a group of female Democratic senators have called on him to resign
3:26PM ( 21 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
House Democrats press Tillerson on Trump's Muslim retweets
A group of House Democrats is demanding that Secretary of State Rex Tillerson tell them whether President Donald Trump's frequent use of social media is putting U.S. diplomats and Americans traveling abroad at risk
3:10PM ( 38 minutes ago )
The Latest: France leader slams Trump's 'regrettable' move
France's leader says President Donald Trump's recognition of Jerusalem as Israel's capital is "a regrettable decision that France does not approve."
2:22PM ( 1 hour ago )
Senate GOP leader OK with deducting local income taxes
The top Senate Republican says he favors expanding a deduction for state and local taxes to enable Americans to deduct local income taxes as well as property taxes
2:22PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Temporary OK for travel ban puts focus on Wednesday hearing
The U.S. Supreme Court's decision allowing President Donald Trump's third travel ban to take effect has intensified the attention on a legal showdown before three judges in Seattle who have previously been cool to the administration's efforts
10:22AM ( 5 hours ago )
Senate OK of Trump judicial picks buoys GOP, Dems dismayed
The pace of confirmations for President Donald Trump's judicial nominees has quickly become a source of pride for Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell and fellow Republicans
3:21AM ( 12 hours ago )
Senate OK of Trump judicial picks buoy GOP, Dems dismayed
The pace of confirmations for President Donald Trump's judicial nominees has quickly become a source of pride for Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell and fellow Republicans
3:15AM ( 12 hours ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
Son of slain black man wants life in prison for ex-officer
The youngest son of a black motorist who was shot to death by a white former police officer has asked a judge to sentence the ex-cop to life in prison
3:25PM ( 23 minutes ago )
Judge detains ricin suspect with prior suicide attempts
A federal judge says a woman accused of manufacturing ricin and testing the deadly toxin on fellow residents of a senior living facility in Vermont has a history of hospitalizations and suicide attempts
3:14PM ( 34 minutes ago )
New blaze erupts in tony Bel Air area of Los Angeles
A dangerous new wildfire erupted in the tony Bel Air area of Los Angeles early Wednesday as firefighters battled three other destructive blazes across Southern California
2:55PM ( 52 minutes ago )
Bannon lambastes GOP leaders in bitter Alabama Senate race
Populist firebrand Steve Bannon has issued a fiery call to rally Alabama voters behind Republican Senate candidate Roy Moore and savaged national Republican leaders
2:53PM ( 55 minutes ago )
House weighs gun bill as ATF reviews 'bump stock' devices
House weighs gun bill as ATF reviews 'bump stock' devices
2:33PM ( 1 hour ago )