clear
Saturday November 25th, 2017 4:39AM

Justices add anti-abortion counseling to free-speech lineup

By The Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court will hear a free speech challenge to a California law that targets anti-abortion crisis pregnancy centers, adding to a term that is loaded with First Amendment disputes.

The justices said Monday they will review the centers' complaint that the new law, pushed by an abortion-rights group, forces them to provide information about abortion and other services.

Lower courts had allowed the law to take effect. Unlicensed centers also must inform clients of their status.

Two other new cases the justices added Monday also involve free-speech claims, by opponents of a Minnesota law banning any political attire at polling places and a Florida man who contends police arrested him in retaliation for voicing his views.

In those cases as well, courts rejected the challengers' constitutional claims.

First Amendment lawyer Floyd Abrams said in an email that "the court's decision to hear three cases in one term in which distinct First Amendment claims had been made and rejected in the lower courts certainly illustrates its intense focus on cases in which freedom of expression is center stage." The Constitution's First Amendment guarantees the right to free speech.

Even before Monday, the justices had major free speech cases on their agenda.

A fight over the politically motivated reshaping of electoral districts, a major case argued last month, could turn on whether the court finds that Republican-drawn districts in Wisconsin penalize Democratic voters because of their political beliefs, in violation of the First Amendment.

Next month, the court will hear the appeal of a Colorado baker who says he should not be compelled to create a cake for a same-sex wedding.

Early next year, the justices will take up an appeal from a government worker in Illinois who says his rights are violated by a state requirement that he pay fees to the labor union that represents public employees.

The concentration of cases fits into a broader pattern that has marked the court under Chief Justice John Roberts, including the bitterly divided Citizens United decision in 2010 and related cases that struck down campaign finance limits.

But other high-profile free speech cases during Roberts' tenure have joined the court's conservative and liberal justices.

"There's a strong bipartisan consensus on the Roberts court to uphold the First Amendment tradition of protecting hate speech," said Jeffrey Rosen, president of the National Constitution Center in Philadelphia. The justices generally support limits on speech only when there's a risk of imminent violence, Rosen said.

The crisis pregnancy center appeal appears to be one of those that is more likely to divide the justices, with Anthony Kennedy as perhaps the pivotal vote.

In urging the court to stay out of the case, California Attorney General Xavier Becerra said the law was intended to make clear to the 700,000 women who become pregnant in the state each year that there is medical care, including abortion, available to people who can't afford it on their own. California said the information the centers must provide falls within well-accepted regulation of businesses and professionals.

But Michael Farris, president of the Alliance Defending Freedom legal group that is representing the centers, said government is picking winners and losers by requiring only centers that oppose abortion to display the information.

"The government should never be permitted to coerce speech it favors over speech it does not favor," Farris said.

A federal appeals court in New York struck down similar provisions of a New York City ordinance, although it upheld the requirement for unlicensed centers to say that they lack a license.

The free-speech issue has arisen in different contexts around the country.

In 2014, the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, based in Richmond, Virginia, struck down a North Carolina law that required abortion providers to show and describe an ultrasound to the pregnant woman. The court said the law is "ideological in intent" and violates doctors' free-speech rights.

In February, the Atlanta-based 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that Florida could not prohibit doctors from talking about gun safety with their patients, upending parts of a 2011 state law. Under the law, doctors faced fines and the possible loss of their medical licenses for discussing guns with patients.

The abortion-rights group NARAL Pro-Choice California was a prime sponsor of the California law. NARAL estimates that 4,000 crisis pregnancy centers operate in the U.S.

The three new cases will be argued in February or March.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Health, AP Business, AP Health - Women's health
© Copyright 2017 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Video recovered, 10 more charged in Penn State frat death
Investigators are filing new charges after recovering deleted security camera footage taken in a Penn State fraternity house basement the night a pledge consumed a dangerous amount of alcohol and suffered fatal injuries
2:25PM ( 7 minutes ago )
The Latest: Iran's death toll from earthquake rises to 445
Iran's semi-official Tasnim news agency is reporting that 445 people were killed and 7,370 injured in the Sunday earthquake along the Iran-Iraq border
2:15PM ( 17 minutes ago )
Bill Gates gives $50 million to combat Alzheimer's
Bill Gates says he's giving $50 million to help fight Alzheimer's disease
2:07PM ( 24 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
UK Scrabble group bans star player for breaking tile rule
The Association of British Scrabble players has banned one of its star players from competition for three years after an independent investigation concluded he had broken the rules of the popular word game
1:41PM ( 50 minutes ago )
Lin-Manuel: Puerto Rican efforts making up for slow start
Lin-Manuel Miranda saluted all the federal workers hard at work in Puerto Rico and says the rebuilding of the island is going well, despite what he considers a slow initial response.
1:38PM ( 53 minutes ago )
McConnell, Roy Moore each insist the other should quit
The top Republican in the Senate says GOP candidate Roy Moore should quit the Alabama race
1:38PM ( 53 minutes ago )
AP National News
Texas may swap US House seniority for staunch conservatism
Three veteran Texas Republicans are bowing out of Congress, meaning the country's largest red state will be trading a serious chunk of House seniority for new perspectives that may prove to be even more conservative
12:31PM ( 2 hours ago )
Trump barges into tax debate, seeks deeper cut for wealthy
President Donald Trump barged into congressional Republicans carefully calibrated work on revamping the nation's tax code, calling for a steeper tax cut for wealthy Americans and pressing to add a contentious health care change to the mix
12:19PM ( 2 hours ago )
Top GOP leader on allegations on Moore: I believe the women
The top Republican in the Senate says GOP candidate Roy Moore should quit the Alabama race
12:01PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Study suggests women less likely to get CPR from bystanders
A new study suggests that women are less likely than men to get CPR from a bystander and are more likely to die
3:14PM ( 23 hours ago )
Schwarzenegger calls on climate activists to change methods
Movie star and former California governor Arnold Schwarzenegger wants environmental activists to give more attention to immediate health hazards like air and water pollution
11:58AM ( 1 day ago )
US cities, states defy Trump, still back Paris climate deal
A group of U.S. states, cities, businesses and universities say they are committed to curbing global warming even as the Trump administration is walking away from the Paris climate accord
7:30PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Health
Italy state museums see record numbers of visitors, revenue
Italian museums are on track for another record-setting year in 2017 in terms of visitors and revenues, with the outdoor Colosseum in Rome and Pompeii near Naples topping the Culture Ministry's most-visited and most-lucrative list
1:33PM ( 58 minutes ago )
South American soccer officials go on trial in New York
A prosecutor at the U.S. trial of three former South American soccer officials say the men took millions of dollars in bribes in a scandal that's shaken the sport's governing body
1:19PM ( 1 hour ago )
Italy museums see record numbers of visitors, revenue
Italian museums are on track for another record-setting year in 2017 in terms of visitors and revenues, with the outdoor Colosseum in Rome and Pompeii near Naples topping the Culture Ministry's most-visited and most-lucrative list
11:47AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Business
Olympic marathon champion Sumgong banned 4 years for EPO
Olympic marathon champion Jemima Sumgong of Kenya has been banned four years for using the blood-booster EPO
1:08PM ( 6 days ago )
Court, for now, blocks immigrant teen's access to abortion
For the time being, an appeals court is blocking an abortion sought by a pregnant 17-year-old immigrant being held in a Texas facility
7:59AM ( 3 weeks ago )
DC court blocks for now immigrant teen's access to abortion
A Washington appeals court is blocking for now an abortion sought by a pregnant 17-year-old immigrant being held in a Texas facility
7:53PM ( 3 weeks ago )
AP Health - Women's health
Video recovered, 10 more charged in Penn State frat death
Investigators are filing new charges after recovering deleted security camera footage taken in a Penn State fraternity house basement the night a pledge consumed a dangerous amount of alcohol and suffered fatal injuries
2:25PM ( 7 minutes ago )
The Latest: Iran's death toll from earthquake rises to 445
Iran's semi-official Tasnim news agency is reporting that 445 people were killed and 7,370 injured in the Sunday earthquake along the Iran-Iraq border
2:15PM ( 17 minutes ago )
McConnell, Roy Moore each insist the other should quit
The top Republican in the Senate says GOP candidate Roy Moore should quit the Alabama race
2:07PM ( 24 minutes ago )
Bill Gates gives $50 million to combat Alzheimer's
Bill Gates says he's giving $50 million to help fight Alzheimer's disease
2:07PM ( 25 minutes ago )
Inmate will get pillow to help him breathe during execution
Ohio's prisons agency is providing a condemned inmate a pillow to help him breathe during his execution this week
2:04PM ( 28 minutes ago )