Monday October 15th, 2018 3:45PM

Church shooting victims face many obstacles in court

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

CHICAGO (AP) — Texas church shooting victims and their families could have a hard time successfully suing the government over the Air Force's failure to submit the gunman's criminal history to the FBI — a step that would have blocked him from legally buying weapons.

Relatives of the more than two dozen churchgoers killed in Sunday's attack would face major obstacles, including protections written into law to shield the military from certain legal action. An easier route might be to seek help from Congress, which could pass a law acknowledging the Air Force's mistake and offering compensation.

A look at some of the key issues involved:



There are just two plausible targets for a lawsuit, legal experts say: Devin Patrick Kelley's estate and the Air Force. Suing for Kelley's assets would be an easy legal win. But it is likely to result in payments of no more than a few hundred dollars to each of the families whose loved ones were killed or wounded.

Targeting the Air Force means taking on the U.S. government. The United States, not the Air Force, would be named in any lawsuit as the defendant. Lawyers from the Department of Justice would represent the government.

At issue would be Kelly's purchase of the Ruger AR-15 used in the attack. The Air Force did not report his 2012 court-martial for abusing his wife and her child to a federal database used for background checks on gun purchasers. Had that conviction been entered into the database, as required by Pentagon rules, Kelley's legal purchase of any gun would have been denied.

Kelley, who worked in logistics at the Holloman Air Force Base in New Mexico starting in 2010, was given 12 months of confinement followed by a bad-conduct discharge in 2014.



The question at the core of any civil case would be: Did the clerical failure by the Air Force cause the deaths in Texas?

Proving such a direct link wouldn't be easy, said Tony Romanucci, a leading personal injury attorney based in Chicago.

"In a regular negligence case, you only have to prove some act was 'a' cause of an injury," he explained. But according to federal statutes that lay out the ground rules for suing the government, "you have to show it is 'the' cause of the injury. ... That is a much, much higher standard."

Government attorneys would have to concede the Air Force error made it easier for Kelley to buy guns. But they would almost certainly argue in court that, by any meaningful definition of cause and effect, Kelley caused the deaths and bears sole responsibility for the killings.



The 1946 Federal Tort Claims Act opened the way for Americans to sue the government. But it and other statutes also leave an important role to laws of the states where the negligence allegedly occurred. A lawsuit filed in federal court in Texas against the U.S., for instance, would use the legal criteria for negligence adopted by Texas.

Federal laws do provide partial shields from legal action to the U.S. government, including the military. For instance, plaintiffs cannot sue the government on the basis that a government policy caused injuries. They must show that a specific wrongful act or negligence by an agency or by a government employee caused the injury — not that the overall policy did.

Federal employees cannot be sued individually. And the military cannot be sued for strategic decisions or commands that lead to soldiers' deaths.



If a lawsuit is filed, the government could choose to seek a settlement before the case gets to trial. But federal authorities have typically dug in to fight litigation for fear that giving in too easily would invite a flood of similar litigation.

One risk of going to trial would be that sympathetic jurors end up awarding plaintiffs far more in damages than they might have been willing to settle for earlier.

"You can't think of a more sympathetic group of individuals — children and worshippers on a Sunday gunned down," Romanucci said. "What they will get ... you are looking at (a potential award of) tens and ten of millions of dollars."



Given the complexities involved in suing a governmental body, it is possible, perhaps even likely, that U.S. district and appellate courts will rule that the Air Force is not liable and dismiss any lawsuits outright, explained Gregory Sisk, a professor at the University of St. Thomas School of Law in Minneapolis.

But, he added, that does not mean compensation by the government is out of the question.

It is within the powers of Congress to pass a new law tailored specifically to the Texas shooting, one that could acknowledge the Air Force's mistake and offer a compensation package.

Though relatively rare, Sisk said, moving the matter from the courts to Congress is an option lawmakers have taken in cases when there's public sympathy for victims of some government action or inaction, such as people who claimed U.S. nuclear tests decades ago made them ill.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News
© Copyright 2018
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
In a race against time, Ridley Scott cuts out Kevin Spacey
Hollywood director Ridley Scott intends to cut a disgraced Kevin Spacey out of his already completed movie, reshoot the actor's scenes and still make a release date just six weeks away
5:38PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Church shooting victims face many obstacles in court
Texas church shooting victims would face many obstacles in court
5:36PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Nevada execution in doubt with paralytic drug out
Nevada's first inmate execution in 11 years is in doubt after a state court judge ordered a paralytic drug removed from a never-before-used lethal injection plan
5:31PM ( 22 minutes ago )
U.S. News
GOP leaders bolt from Senate candidate Moore after sex claim
GOP leaders bolt from Senate candidate Roy Moore after the former Alabama judge is accused of having sexual contact decades ago with a girl of 14
5:47PM ( 7 minutes ago )
Report: 5 women accuse Louis C.K. of sexual misconduct
Comedian Louis C.K. is accused of sexual misconduct, including masturbating in front of them, in a New York Times report
5:44PM ( 9 minutes ago )
John Paul I closer to sainthood as book debunks conspiracies
Pope Francis has moved Pope John Paul I _ the pope who reigned for only 33 days in 1978 _ a step closer to possible sainthood
5:32PM ( 22 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Judge jails, sets bail for top lawmaker in Catalonia probe
Spanish judge jails Catalonia's top lawmaker in rebellion probe stemming from an independence declaration, sets bail at $175,000
5:11PM ( 43 minutes ago )
Lebanese PM's fate in doubt amid Saudi-Lebanon escalation
In new escalation, Saudi Arabia orders citizens out of Lebanon and Beirut demands Lebanese PM return home from kingdom
4:36PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Distributor reviewing Louis C.K. film release
Distributor reviewing release of Louis C.K. film
4:22PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
20 GOP House members urge Speaker Ryan to act on immigration
Nearly two dozen House Republicans are pressing Speaker Paul Ryan to act quickly on legislation that would protect some 800,000 young immigrants brought illegally to the U.S. as children
2:24PM ( 3 hours ago )
Despite Trump's scorn, early 'Obamacare' sign-ups top 600k
Despite Trump's scorn for 'Obamacare,' sign-ups top 600k in first week
1:55PM ( 3 hours ago )
House panel to interview Russian-American lobbyist, Sessions
The House intelligence committee is preparing to interview Rinat Akhmetshin, a Russian-American lobbyist who attended a meeting at Trump Tower last year with President Donald Trump's son
1:50PM ( 4 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Industrial and tech stocks fall on potential tax cut delay
US stocks slide after Senate Republicans propose delaying a cut in corporate tax rates for a year
4:58PM ( 56 minutes ago )
The Latest: Top Catalan lawmaker jailed, but gets bail set
A Spanish judge has agreed to jail Catalonia's top lawmaker in the rebellion probe stemming from the regional parliament's independence vote, setting her bail at 150,000 euros ($175,000) and ordering her passport confiscated
4:31PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: White House hails 'important step' on tax bill
The White House is praising the House Ways and Means Committee for approving the Republican Party's tax cut package
4:12PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Technology slump leads US stock indexes sharply lower
US stocks are down as technology stocks take sharp losses that threaten to end a 10-day winning streak for the sector
2:13PM ( 3 hours ago )
The Latest: House about-face on deduction for adoption
House Republicans are restoring the adoption tax credit to their overhaul legislation after protests by family advocate groups and other interests
2:11PM ( 3 hours ago )
Catalan lawmakers testify in separatist rebellion probe
Six Catalan lawmakers are testifying before a Spanish judge over claims that they ignored Constitutional Court orders and allowed an independence vote in Catalonia's regional parliament
2:00PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
In a race against time, Ridley Scott cuts out Kevin Spacey
Hollywood director Ridley Scott intends to cut a disgraced Kevin Spacey out of his already completed movie, reshoot the actor's scenes and still make a release date just six weeks away
5:38PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Nevada execution in doubt with paralytic drug out
Nevada's first inmate execution in 11 years is in doubt after a state court judge ordered a paralytic drug removed from a never-before-used lethal injection plan
5:31PM ( 23 minutes ago )
Senate GOP tax bill would delay biz cut, undo deductions
The Senate unveils its version of the Republicans' high-stakes tax overhaul with billions in tax cuts for people and corporations and repeal of the federal deduction for state and local taxes.
5:21PM ( 33 minutes ago )
Pastor: Texas church that was attacked will be demolished
Pastor of Texas church that was attacked says building will be demolished
4:31PM ( 1 hour ago )
Family: Woman killed in church shooting shielded grandson
One of the people killed when a gunman opened fire at a small-town Texas church was a 56-year-old Sunday school teacher who relatives say threw herself in front of her 18-year-old grandson
4:30PM ( 1 hour ago )