Tuesday December 18th, 2018 2:18PM

What's next for a Grand Canyon tram? Prospects are bleak

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

FLAGSTAFF, Ariz. (AP) — Lawmakers on the country's largest American Indian reservation have shot down a measure to build an aerial tram to take visitors to a riverside boardwalk in the Grand Canyon, with stores, hotels and restaurants above on the East Rim.

The chances of moving forward with the Grand Canyon Escalade project now appear slim. One tribal delegate who voted for it this week says it has no chance with current lawmakers. Developers have not said what they will do next.

The legislation was opposed by environmentalists and outdoor enthusiasts who are trying to keep open spaces wild. At the same time, the Trump administration is moving to free up other federal land for development.

If the tram was approved by the Navajo Nation, whose reservation borders the East Rim of the Grand Canyon, federal agencies would have had to review it.

Here's a closer look at the tram and development in the Grand Canyon region:



Developers proposed the multimillion-dollar aerial tram as an economic savior, with up to 3,500 jobs for the reservation where unemployment hovers around 50 percent. Visitors would board gondolas from the East Rim to a 1,400-foot boardwalk near the confluence of the Colorado and Little Colorado rivers, a site that tribes say is sacred.

Navajo lawmakers won't take up the same legislation again. A new measure could be introduced and moved through Tribal Council committees, but it appears unlikely. The reservation has an election next year, and Navajo President Russell Begaye says he won't support any agreement for the project.



The Scottsdale-based developers, Confluence Partners LLC, have not responded to repeated messages from The Associated Press about their next move.

Former Navajo President Ben Shelly, whose administration negotiated the project, said Thursday that developers should be more visible in tribal communities and better educate people if they want another shot.

"Don't just leave everything and say it's dead and gone," he said. "Next year's an election. A lot of people will be campaigning, a lot of people will be talking."

Opponents say they will remain vigilant while eyeing other possibilities for economic development.

"We never said we were against economic development but, please, not in our sacred space," activist Renae Yellowhorse said.



The aerial tram was proposed in a remote area where the federal government banned construction for more than 40 years because of a now-resolved land dispute between the Navajos and their Hopi neighbors.

Navajos hold grazing permits and home site leases but no one lives at the East Rim of the Grand Canyon. It has no running water or electricity.

The tribe will be hit hard with the expected 2019 closure of the coal-fired Navajo Generating Station and its supply mine, which employ many on the reservation.

Tribal Delegate Leonard Tsosie said he considered those revenue losses in voting for the project this week.

"It's fun to protest and it's fun to say we don't want these developments, but I think in reality, if we don't raise money to replace the loss from NGS, we are going to be hurting," he said Thursday.

Yellowhorse says the tribe can take advantage of tourist traffic with motels, truck stops and the reservation's natural features.

"The possibilities are endless once the community starts the healing and once they work together," she said.



Tram developers told Navajo lawmakers they knew of no sacred sites at the East Rim but pledged to protect traditional cultural properties.

Hopis say they make pilgrimages near the confluence of the rivers as part of a ritual initiation for young men, keep religious shrines and gather agave plants. Zuni Pueblo leaders say the area warrants special protection.

A group of Navajo medicine people said development would harm the sacred qualities of the confluence, rendering ceremonies meant to cure illness less effective.

Lamar Whitmer of Confluence Partners said earlier this month that developers moved the boardwalk away from the rivers to ease concerns and wondered how sharing the area with the world would affect it.

"It doesn't," he said. "It makes the site more special because you're telling people why it's special."



Developers used estimates from Grand Canyon National Park tourism to anticipate the popularity of the aerial tram. Nearly 6 million people visit the park each year.

On the west end of the Grand Canyon, the Hualapai Tribe operates a horseshoe-shaped glass bridge along its stretch of the natural wonder. It gets 1 million tourists a year, mostly though bus tours booked out of Las Vegas.

The Havasupai reservation, deep in a gorge off the Grand Canyon, also draws tourists with its blue-green waterfalls. Its campgrounds in the village of Supai are booked months in advance.

The small town of Tusayan outside the South Rim entrance is voting next week on a proposed increase to building heights that would lead to homes, more hotels and retail shops.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Entertainment, AP Business, AP Business - Economy
© Copyright 2018
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
What's next for a Grand Canyon tram? Prospects are bleak
The chances of moving a project to build an aerial tram on a tribe's slice of the Grand Canyon forward appear bleak
5:29PM ( 7 minutes ago )
Trump nominates Jerome Powell to be next Fed chairman
Trump nominates Fed board member Jerome Powell to be next Fed chairman
5:28PM ( 8 minutes ago )
Trump's tweets seen as unlikely to slow New York terror case
President Donald Trump's tweets calling for the death penalty for the man accused in the New York truck rampage could be seized on by defense attorneys as evidence of bias
5:25PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
US stocks end mixed on tax proposals and shaky forecasts
US stocks finished mixed as House Republicans' tax cut proposals give smaller companies a boost, but home improvement retailers and homebuilders fall as the plan calls for reducing the tax deduction for interest on mortgage payments
4:58PM ( 37 minutes ago )
Alaskans differ as Senate debates drilling in Arctic refuge
Alaskans are bringing the debate over oil drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge to Congress
4:53PM ( 43 minutes ago )
The Latest: Catalan police step in to shield Spain officers
A crowd shouting slogans against the Spanish police has gathered outside a court building in Barcelona that was being guarded by officers from the national force
4:49PM ( 47 minutes ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
The Latest: Catalan parties demand protests over jailings
The spokeswoman for the Catalan republican left party ERC has called on "democrats" to protest at the decision to jail politicians over independence declaration
3:50PM ( 1 hour ago )
Tillerson to make 1st trip to Myanmar amid Rohingya crisis
Top U.S. diplomat Rex Tillerson will make his first trip to Myanmar this month to discuss the humanitarian crisis in Rakhine State
3:31PM ( 2 hours ago )
The Latest: Trump kisses Republican tax plan
President Donald Trump has planted a kiss on a symbol of the House Republican tax plan
3:26PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Media restricted from gun, political questions at CMA Awards
The Country Music Association is warning media outlets to avoid questions about a recent mass shooting at a country music festival, gun rights or political affiliations at their annual awards show next week or risk losing credentials
4:48PM ( 48 minutes ago )
The Latest: 'Late Show' cancels pre-taped Piven interview
The Latest: 'Late Show' cancels pre-taped Jeremy Piven interview because it says show can't address 'recent developments' that include a sexual harassment allegation against the Emmy winner
4:47PM ( 49 minutes ago )
Weinstein's ex-company wants sworn testimony from producer
Attorneys for the company co-founded by film mogul Harvey Weinstein say they want to depose him in a lawsuit he filed seeking his employment file and emails
1:14PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Entertainment
Settlement talks continue in suit over 13-year-old oil leak
A company that has failed to stop a 13-year-old oil leak in the Gulf of Mexico is asking for more time to negotiate a settlement that could allow it to recover millions of dollars it set aside for work to end the leak
4:57PM ( 39 minutes ago )
Pressure mounts on Apple to live up to hype for the iPhone X
Pressure mounts on Apple to live up to hype for the iPhone X
4:46PM ( 51 minutes ago )
US makes final finding on Canadian softwood imports
The U.S. Department of Commerce has issued its final determination on the softwood lumber duties Canadian producers will pay
4:31PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
GOP tax plan would slash corporate rate, help wealthiest
House Republicans unveil a tax cut plan that would slash the rate for businesses and also lower taxes for most Americans. But it would limit a cherished deduction for homeowners
1:33PM ( 4 hours ago )
The Latest: Appeals planned over Catalan officials' jailing
Lawyers for nine former members of the Catalan regional government ordered jailed say the defendants are serene and want the people of Catalonia to stay calm
1:04PM ( 4 hours ago )
The Latest: Judge jails ex-members of Catalan government
A Spanish judge has ordered nine ex-members of government in Catalonia jailed while they are investigated on possible charges of sedition, rebellion and embezzlement
12:14PM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Business - Economy
Trump's tweets seen as unlikely to slow New York terror case
President Donald Trump's tweets calling for the death penalty for the man accused in the New York truck rampage could be seized on by defense attorneys as evidence of bias
5:25PM ( 11 minutes ago )
The Latest: Walmart suspect left work early before shooting
The roofing company boss of a man suspected of fatally shooting three people at a suburban Denver Walmart says the suspect walked away from his job without warning the morning of the shooting
5:09PM ( 27 minutes ago )
Thompson's injury another blow for struggling Cavaliers
Cavaliers forward Tristan Thompson could miss a month because of calf strain
5:09PM ( 27 minutes ago )
Menendez jury hears competing theories in closing arguments
Jurors have heard contrasting views on the bribery case against U.S. Sen. Bob Menendez and a wealthy friend
5:07PM ( 29 minutes ago )
Suspect in Colorado Walmart killings called hostile loner
A man arrested on suspicion of fatally shooting three people inside a Colorado Walmart has been described by neighbors as a hostile loner
4:58PM ( 38 minutes ago )