clear
Friday November 24th, 2017 5:11PM

Rebel GOP lawmakers send message to leaders on budget vote

By The Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) — A bloc of GOP House lawmakers from high-tax states mustered a show of force Thursday that nearly sank the Republican budget setting up a major overhaul of the tax system, the party's prime political goal and economic promise.

The rebellious lawmakers, from states such as New York and New Jersey, oppose the targeting of a prized deduction in the tax plan pushed by President Donald Trump and Republican congressional leaders.

The lawmakers insist the elimination of the federal deduction for state and local taxes would hurt many of their constituents and subject them to being taxed twice.

The breakaway bloc isn't a solid block, though. Its members have widely differing definitions of what's best for their constituents' economic interests and who makes up the middle class.

The razor-thin 216-212 vote in the House for the budget allows Republicans to begin work on a follow-up $1.5 trillion tax cut and move it through Congress without fear of blocking tactics by Democrats.

Among the 20 Republicans who bucked their party to oppose the budget measure were 11 lawmakers from New York and New Jersey, who had supported the plan earlier this month but now registered their unhappiness over the imperiled state-local deduction.

A fevered series of meetings in recent weeks with top Republican leaders failed to produce a compromise to mollify the rebels. They began huddling anew minutes after the budget vote.

"We stood firm ... to let them know we're not kidding," said Rep. John Katko, R-N.Y., a "no" vote on the budget.

Rep. Steve Scalise, the House Republican whip, promised to keep negotiating with the breakaway lawmakers: "We're committed to working with them to try to fix it."

"Obviously it's complicated," Scalise said. "It all deals with how people, especially in the middle class and upper-middle class, are going to be able to still benefit from our tax-cut plan."

Rep. Lee Zeldin, R-N.Y., said the Republicans were given assurances that "there's change coming."

In fact, while Republicans are fractured along various lines over the tax plan, the bloc of high-tax state Republicans isn't speaking with one voice. And they're all claiming to carry the standard for the middle class.

Rep. Tom Reed says 99 percent of his district in western New York "will not be impacted" if the state-local deduction were repealed. He voted for the budget measure and totally supports the tax plan. Rep. Peter King, whose Long Island, New York district boasts high living costs and a large contingent of lower-salaried public employees like teachers and police officers, voted against the budget plan and may need some accommodation to move to a "yes" on the tax legislation.

Lawmakers representing wealthy suburbs in New York and New Jersey have a different take. High state income taxes can affect residents in the same areas unevenly. A local property tax bill of $25,000 in one jurisdiction brings vastly different hits to income and tax breaks in another.

And what exactly is middle class, anyway? Is it the so-called middle quintile (fifth section) of incomes as defined by economists, $44,000 to $72,000 a year per household, or the next higher one, $72,000 to $112,000?

The Republican tax plan hasn't yet attached income levels to its proposed new tax brackets: three or four, at rates of 12 percent, 25 percent, 35 percent and to be determined.

Possible compromises under consideration, short of repealing the state-local deduction entirely, include capping the annual income level for using the deduction at between $250,000 and $400,000, and a new property tax credit to replace the deduction of local property taxes.

Other fractures among the Republicans over taxes also persist. A battle over tax-deferred contributions to 401(k) retirement savings accounts has broken open, and GOP tax writers have yet to lock down dozens of crucial details on tax rates and preferences. Republicans may also drop efforts to fully repeal taxes on multimillion-dollar estates, even though the idea is a longstanding feature of the party's tax agenda.

___

This story has been corrected to show that the proposed tax rate for the lowest bracket is 12 percent, not 15 percent.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business, AP Business - Economy
© Copyright 2017 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Trump names Treasury official to be acting IRS commissioner
The White House is naming a Treasury official to serve as acting commissioner of the Internal Revenue Service, succeeding an IRS commissioner who has drawn the ire of congressional Republicans
4:37PM ( 15 minutes ago )
American and Southwest signal rising airline fares ahead
Third-quarter profit rises at Southwest and falls at American, but both airlines hint at higher prices the rest of the year
4:33PM ( 18 minutes ago )
The Latest: Kenya police say 3 dead in protests over vote
The Latest: Kenya police say 3 dead in confrontations over repeat presidential election
4:29PM ( 22 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Will JFK files answer questions? Probably not all
Students of history are waiting to leap on JFK assassination files. Will they answer questions?
4:14PM ( 38 minutes ago )
Democrats condemn proposed fee hikes at national parks
Democratic senators are harshly criticizing a National Park Service plan to impose steep increases in entrance fees at 17 of its most popular parks, including the Grand Canyon, Yosemite, Yellowstone and Zion
4:09PM ( 43 minutes ago )
House backs $4T budget, faces challenges on Trump tax plan
Republicans powered a $4 trillion budget through the House on Thursday, but only by a razor-thin margin that underscored the difficulties ahead on delivering President Donald Trump's promise to cuts taxes
3:59PM ( 52 minutes ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Menendez gets support of colleagues as mistrial motion looms
Two high-profile colleagues of Democratic Sen. Bob Menendez have testified on his behalf at his bribery trial, while defense lawyers say they'll file for a mistrial based on the judge's rulings.
3:32PM ( 1 hour ago )
Brazil's Temer turns to reforms, but can he deliver?
Brazilian President Michel Temer has overcome an effort to try him on corruption charges. Now he's trying to move past the scandals that have dogged him, though it's unclear if he has the support to push his market-friendly reform agenda.
3:25PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Spain panel passes takeover plan for Catalonia
A Spain Senate commission has approved the government's proposal for taking over the running of the country's powerful Catalonia region to stop its push for independence
3:23PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Congress News
Russian editor says newspaper plans to arm its journalists
The editor of Russia's most prominent opposition newspaper says he intends to arm his staff with nominally non-lethal pistols, amid growing concern about attacks on journalists
4:13PM ( 39 minutes ago )
Crossing a Honolulu street? Don't text to avoid a fine
A new Honolulu law allows police officers to issue tickets to pedestrians caught looking at a cellphone or other electronic device while crossing a street
4:08PM ( 44 minutes ago )
Ashley Judd says a 'deal' helped her flee from Weinstein
Actress Ashley Judd says she escaped Harvey Weinstein's sexual advances by making a deal. She says she told him, yes, she would submit to him
3:53PM ( 59 minutes ago )
AP Business
Trump names Treasury official to be acting IRS commissioner
The White House is naming a Treasury official to serve as acting commissioner of the Internal Revenue Service, succeeding an IRS commissioner who has drawn the ire of congressional Republicans
4:37PM ( 15 minutes ago )
American and Southwest signal rising airline fares ahead
Third-quarter profit rises at Southwest and falls at American, but both airlines hint at higher prices the rest of the year
4:33PM ( 19 minutes ago )
The Latest: Kenya police say 3 dead in protests over vote
The Latest: Kenya police say 3 dead in confrontations over repeat presidential election
4:29PM ( 23 minutes ago )
The Latest: HHS follows Trump in declaring health emergency
The acting health and human services secretary has officially declared the opioid crisis a nationwide public health emergency, as requested by President Donald Trump
4:23PM ( 28 minutes ago )
With many injured skiers out, Vonn set for surprise GS start
Big names set to miss season-opening World Cup ski races but Lindsey Vonn unexpectedly starts
4:23PM ( 29 minutes ago )