clear
Wednesday January 17th, 2018 9:04PM

Consumer watchdog structure ruled unconstitutional

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — The U.S. consumer watchdog agency, enmeshed in partisan politics since its creation after the financial crisis, now has had its structure ruled unconstitutional because it gives too much power to a single agency director.

A federal appeals court ruled Tuesday that the way the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau is organized violates the Constitution's separation of powers by limiting the president's ability to remove the director who heads the agency.

The law creating the independent agency after the 2008-09 crisis says its director can only be removed "for cause," such as neglect of duty, and not over political differences. The court said that conflicts with the Constitution, which allows the president to remove executives for any reason.

That problem can be solved, the court said, by taking out the "for cause" provision — giving the president the power to remove the director at will, and to supervise him or her. The CFPB's operations will not be affected.

The ruling came from a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit.

A few actions taken by the agency might have to be reviewed because they didn't conform with the law in the appeals judges' view. Maria Earley, an attorney at law firm Reed Smith who was a CFPB enforcement attorney, said a handful of cases could be affected.

While the constitutional questions raised by the court are significant, "It's important to recognize the remedy the court outlines still allows the CFPB to continue to operate," Earley said.

The ruling handed a victory to the banking industry, which has viewed the agency as a thorn in its side and accused it of overreaching in its regulation of consumer financial activities. The agency has taken legal action against banks, mortgage companies, credit card issuers, payday lenders, debt collectors and others. The CFPB says that over five years it has recovered $11.7 billion that it returned to more than 27 million harmed consumers.

Consumer groups said the court's decision undermines financial protections.

The agency has been a political lightning rod since it was created by Congress in a major financial overhaul law in 2010 to protect consumers from harmful banking and lending practices. Wall Street interests, the banking and consumer finance industries and Republicans in Congress have fiercely opposed and criticized the agency.

Richard Cordray, a Democrat and former Ohio attorney general, has run the agency since it began operating in July 2011. His term doesn't expire until 2018, so his tenure likely won't be affected unless Republican Donald Trump were to win the presidency.

As the agency's director, Cordray exercises more power than would be the case with a five-member commission, which is often the structure atop independent federal agencies. The members of such commissions normally are split between the political parties.

"The director of the CFPB possesses enormous power over American business, American consumers and the overall U.S. economy," the appeals court ruling said. "That combination of power that is massive in scope, concentrated in a single person and unaccountable to the president triggers the important constitutional question at issue in this case."

One of the judges, Karen Henderson, dissented partially from the ruling. She said she doesn't believe it's necessary to reach a conclusion on whether the agency's structure is constitutional in order to resolve the case.

The government had argued that the agency's structure and powers are constitutional.

The case involves allegations that New Jersey mortgage lender PHH Corp. was involved in a scheme to refer customers to certain mortgage insurance companies in exchange for illegal kickbacks. The CFPB ordered PHH to pay $109 million in illegal payments it had received. PHH claims its conduct was legal and challenged the bureau's structure as unconstitutional.

The Obama administration could seek a rehearing of the decision before the full appeals court, which would be the next step in the legal process. The full court has a majority of judges appointed by Democratic presidents, while all three judges on the panel that issued the ruling were named by Republican presidents.

"The bureau respectfully disagrees with the court's decision," CFPB spokeswoman Moira Vahey said. "The bureau believes that Congress' decision to make the director removable only for cause is consistent with Supreme Court precedent, and the bureau is considering options for seeking further review of the court's decision."

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Business, AP Business - Consumer News, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Business - Economy, AP Business - Financial Markets, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Financial Services, AP Business - Personal Finance
© Copyright 2018 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Revelers say goodbye to a year of conflicts, deadly violence
People around the world are bidding a weary adieu to a year filled with political surprises, prolonged conflicts, deadly attacks at gatherings and celebrity deaths
11:58PM ( 1 year ago )
Get ready for a blockbuster sequel: Alabama vs. Clemson
Get ready for a blockbuster sequel: Alabama vs. Clemson, The Rematch
11:31PM ( 1 year ago )
With Ohio State shutout, Clemson earns another shot at 'Bama
Clemson's redemption: By shutting out Ohio State, the Tigers earn another shot at 'Bama
11:25PM ( 1 year ago )
Associated Press (AP)
New UN chief wants consensus but faces antagonistic Trump
Antonio Guterres took the reins of the United Nations on New Year's Day, promising to be a "bridge-builder" but facing an antagonistic incoming U.S. administration led by Donald Trump who thinks the world body's 193 member states do nothing except talk
9:39PM ( 1 year ago )
US states, leery of Russia malware, re-examine cybersecurity
Several U.S. states are asking cybersecurity experts to re-examine state and utility networks after a malware code U.S. officials say is linked to Russian hackers was found on a Vermont utility's laptop
8:57PM ( 1 year ago )
States re-examine cybersecurity after Russia accused of hack
Several U.S. states are asking cybersecurity experts to re-examine state and utility networks after a malware code U.S. officials say is linked to Russian hackers was found on a Vermont utility's laptop
6:37PM ( 1 year ago )
AP Business
Tech leaders to make peace, or press their case, with Trump
Technology leaders are about to come face-to-face with President-elect Donald Trump after fiercely opposing his candidacy, fearful that he would stifle innovation, curb the hiring of computer-savvy immigrants and infringe on consumers' digital privacy
1:06PM ( 1 year ago )
Tech leaders couldn't beat Trump; they'll meet him instead
Technology leaders are about to come face-to-face with President-elect Donald Trump after fiercely opposing his candidacy, fearful that he would stifle innovation, curb the hiring of computer-savvy immigrants and infringe on consumers' digital privacy
12:47PM ( 1 year ago )
GOP leaders predict House passage of medical research bill
Republican leaders are predicting House passage of a compromise medical research bill on Wednesday
11:04AM ( 1 year ago )
AP Business - Consumer News
Coast Guard suspends search for missing plane with 6 onboard
The U.S. Coast Guard has suspended its search for a plane that was carrying a beverage distribution company's chief executive and five other people when it vanished over Lake Erie after takeoff from Cleveland's lakeshore airport
8:19PM ( 1 year ago )
Nvidia leads S&P's winners in 2016; drug companies slump
Chipmaker Nvidia more than tripled in value in 2016, far more than any other company in the S&P 500
4:44PM ( 1 year ago )
US stocks move lower in afternoon trading; oil heads down
Technology companies are leading U.S. stock indexes modestly lower this afternoon on the final day of trading for the year
2:31PM ( 1 year ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
Rural New Mexico exports mentoring model for physicians
A mentoring program for physicians in rural areas is being tapped by the federal government to expand access to specialized care
1:41PM ( 1 year ago )
China says it will shut down ivory trade by end of 2017
China says it will shut down its ivory trade by the end of 2017 in a move designed to curb the mass slaughter of African elephants
7:30PM ( 1 year ago )
US stocks end modestly lower on final trading day of 2016
Investors end a year of solid gains on Wall Street in a selling mood, sending the major U.S. stock indexes modestly lower in the final trading day of 2016
6:18PM ( 1 year ago )
AP Business - Economy
What it means if Trump names China a currency manipulator
President-elect Donald Trump may have a problem putting any bite in his vow to name China a currency manipulator on his first day in office
11:44AM ( 1 year ago )
Global stocks edge lower after Wall Street's slide
Global shares are mostly lower in thin trading Thursday, taking their cues from a slide on Wall Street
7:18AM ( 1 year ago )
Asian stocks fall in thin trading after Wall Street's slide
Asian shares mostly dropped in thin trading Thursday, taking their cues from a slide on Wall Street as the stronger yen helped send Japanese stocks lower
12:05AM ( 1 year ago )
AP Business - Financial Markets
India's Modi defends decision to demonetize high-value bills
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi has defended his government's decision to demonetize the country's highest-value currency bills last month in an unusual New Year's Eve message to the nation
1:58PM ( 1 year ago )
States face off over future of Obama global warming plan
Two weeks after Republican officials in two dozen states asked Republican President-elect Donald Trump to kill one of Democratic President Barack Obama's plans to curb global warming, another group of state officials is urging Trump to save it
3:36PM ( 1 year ago )
Italian premier chides ECB for lack of transparency
Italy's premier says he was taken aback by the European Central Bank's move to significantly increase the amount of money that troubled bank Monte dei Paschi will need
12:51PM ( 1 year ago )
AP Business - Industries
Deutsche, Credit Suisse to compensate consumers post-crisis
Nine years after the collapse of the U.S. housing market sent shockwaves through the global economy, two big European banks have agreed to offer American homeowners and borrowers billions of dollars' worth of help
12:02PM ( 1 year ago )
Italy rescues Monte dei Paschi after it fails to get cash
The Italian government is rescuing Monte dei Paschi di Siena after Italy's third-largest lender failed to raise the 5 billion euros ($5.2 billion) it needed to stay afloat
4:18AM ( 1 year ago )
'Obamacare' holding its own: 6.4M signed up so far
The Obama administration says 6.4 million people have signed up so far this year for subsidized private insurance coverage through HealthCare.gov
5:50PM ( 1 year ago )
AP Business - Financial Services
How to spend more mindfully in the new year
Meditation and mindfulness can help with anxiety, depression and more
10:48AM ( 1 year ago )
Long-term US mortgage rates rise, staying near 2014 highs
Long-term US mortgage rates ticked up again this week, staying at their highest levels since early 2014
10:00AM ( 1 year ago )
Where to sell your unwanted stuff online and earn extra cash
If you're cleaning out your closets for the new year, or need some spare cash after the holidays, your old stuff can help fill up your wallet
2:26PM ( 1 year ago )
AP Business - Personal Finance
Women get prominent media jobs in wake of misconduct ousters
As more than two dozen men have lost media jobs or projects after sexual misconduct accusations in the last several months, their departures have opened doors for a handful of women.
10:33AM ( 21 minutes ago )
The New York Times cancels public event with James Franco
The New York Times cancels public event with James Franco days after the Golden Globe winner was accused of sexual misconduct
10:20AM ( 34 minutes ago )
The Latest: Trump calls court system 'broken and unfair'
President Donald Trump says the U.S. court system is _ in his words _ "broken and unfair."
9:59AM ( 55 minutes ago )
James Franco's says allegations he's heard aren't accurate
The New York Times cancels public event with James Franco days after the Golden Globe winner was accused of sexual misconduct
9:58AM ( 56 minutes ago )
Deaths threats cause lockdown after teacher handcuffed video
A Louisiana school board's office went on temporary lockdown after getting death threats from around the world in response to widely viewed video of a teacher screaming while being handcuffed at a school board meeting
9:53AM ( 1 hour ago )